The Serious Pizza People. 442-1000
A Rochester tradition since 1986 1921 South Ave. Rochester, NY

Pizza Toppings

Extra Mozzarella
Cup and Char Pepperoni
Italian Sausage
Sweet Peppers
Hot Peppers
Black Olives
Ricotta cheese
Roasted red peppers

Sub Topping Choices

Sub Topping choices: lettuce, tomatoes, onions, mustard, horseradish, oil, or mayo.  Your choice of cheese: Provolone, American, Pepper Jack or Swiss.

Sub Extras (50¢ each): olives, mushrooms, hot or sweet peppers. Double toppings extra.


Today's Hours:

Mr Shoes Pizza is currently Open

Place your online order now

Hours of Operation

Sunday - Thursday
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM

Friday & Saturday
11:00 AM - 10:00 PM

Mr Shoes will accept orders up to 15 minutes before closing.


Home Menu Coupons Area Map Hours About Contact Order Online

About Mr. Shoes

Mr. Shoes Pizza, located at the end of South Avenue near University of Rochester, Strong Memorial Hospital and Monroe Community College, is home of the "Serious Pizza People".  Each hand-tossed pizza is made from fresh and flavorful homemade pizza dough, covered in our secret recipe pizza sauce, and topped with the highest quality meats, cheeses, and veggies.  Each and every one of our pizzas is created with the TLC that keeps our loyal customers coming back for more.

So many choices...

In addition to great pizza, we also offer a wide range of other choices including jumbo chicken wings with homemade sauces, hot and cold subs with rolls baked fresh daily, gourmet bread bowl salads, and award winning Burger & Hot Dog Plates from the grill.

Mr. Shoes offers take out, delivery, catering, and corporate account ordering for your convenience.  Our delivery area covers Henrietta, Brighton, the South Wedge of Rochester, Monroe Avenue, and Park Avenue areas and includes many local schools, businesses, and residents.  We also have a cozy dining area, so stop in for lunch and grab one of our huge pizza slices.

Order by phone at 442-1000, or use our quick and easy online ordering system. A bonus - every order placed online can earn you loyalty points in our Sole Saver Program! Points earned can be used toward payment for future online orders.

Corporate Accounts

Place your large pizza and wings orders easier and faster by opening a corporate account! We happily accept corporate and catering accounts with local businesses and institutions. Please contact us at 442-1000 for further information. 

Download and fill out this form  to submit your application today!

Our customers

Some of the great feedback we get from our happy customers!*

“I like their pizza a lot, and their wings have an interesting spice mix in the breading. My personal favorite pizza in Rochester.”


“Your chicken wing pizza is the best I've ever had...we love it and usually make it a point to come in at least once a week.”

—Mary S.

“I've ordered from the South Ave location. The food is very good, but I have a few favorites. The wings are always good, cooked perfectly. The potato pizza is to die for. Think of pizza with no sauce, home fried potatoes, mozzarella and cheddar cheeses, bacon and green onions with ranch or bleu cheese on the side. OMG, the best stuff ever.”


“The South Ave location is the best pizza in the area, and at a really fair price. 7.99 pickup special and the resuable $2.00 off a large when you want delivery make it both affordable and high quality...”


“My new place to order pizza from (South Ave) after Piatza's stopped accepting their coupons without expiration dates. The pizza is pretty good hot, tasty leftover, and the girls who work at the counter when I pick it up are always really nice!”


“My favorite pizza place in Rochester. They have, hands down, the best wings around. The sauce is homemade (so I assume...) It's always slightly different and has an amazing flavor. The pizza is great too. The ingredients taste fresh and I'm a fan of the liberal amount of sauce as well as the doughy crust. I haven't tried any of the things SaraChristine has mentioned, but only because I can't pry myself away from the pizza+wings combo! ”


“One of my favorite pizza places in town for non-gourmet pizza. I find the crust to be good (thick) the cheese is fresh, and the sauce is tasty.”


*courtesy of and Mr. Shoes Pizza online comments